Let's face it. Mail-in voting was growing before the pandemic; its explosion in 2020 probably cost Donald Trump his re-election; and expansion is a major strategy for Pelosi's Democratic party. While there is a litany of issues and challenges surrounding the presidential election, most are reminiscent of past alleged misdeeds; the big change, and the major challenge for future reliable elections, is the shift from in person voting (with voter identification in most states), to mail-in voting where the validity and chain of custody of the ballots is questionable. If the public is going to believe in the results of elections , it is essential that "best practices" be established. Since a majority of mail in ballots are Democratic, it is essential for Republicans that only legitimate ballots be counted.
A brief history:
- From 1996 to 2016, the portion of voters using mail-in ballots in presidential elections increased from about 8% to about 21%, with participation ranging from states using exclusively mail in ballots (Colorado; Oregon; Washington), to 29 states allowing anyone who wishes to vote by mail, to 18 states requiring a reason such as travel, military service, or physical disability. Some 70 % of the public believes that such voting should be easily allowed, so there is no going back.
- In the 2020 presidential election almost half voted by mail with the rest split evenly between voting on election day and voting in person early. Utah and Hawaii joined the exclusive mail states, many states expanded their approval criteria, and only five (all Trump states) made no special accomodation. Other than Utah, Biden carried the all-mail states.
- According to Pew Resarch, 33% of Trump voters voted by mail, while 58% of the Biden voters did. ( 37 per cent of Trump voters voted at the polls on election day; only 17 per cent of Biden voters did. Early on-site voting was similar.) Some of the disparity is due to large Democratic states like California, but a substantial portion of the mail vote is Democratic across the board and correlates with age.
- Upon assuming the House speakership in 2019, Nancy Pelosi's first priority was House Resolution 1, election reform, which would highlight mail voting, restrict scrubbing of voter rolls, and expand the California system which automatically enrolls drivers license registrants, sends ballots to all registered voters, and allows "ballot harvesting". Similar provisions were included in unsuccessful coronavirus relief packages. Her expectation: a shift of the electorate to the Left by several percentage points.
A proper bill to restore confidence in the American voting system should contain the following provisions:
1. Bipartisan commissions to oversee state Secretary of State efforts to clean up the voter rolls, eliminating those who have moved or died, felons, and non-citizens. (At one point the California rolls held tens of thousands of illegal immigrants with drivers licenses.)
2. Ballots provided on request only. Reasons required - if any - to be determined by the state.
3. Submission by US Mail or drop-off by individual, family member, or other designated care giver. Criminal offense to gather ballots from groups of others. Partisan ballot harvesting as sponsored by Tom Steyer in California in 2018 to be prohibited.
4. Signature on envelope compared to that on voter rolls prior to ballot being separated from the envolope. Machine scanning preferred.
5. Ballots to be received by elections office by Close of Business on election day.
6. Ballot requests by mail or internet. Outbound postage government responsibility; inbound postage voter responsibility.
7. Sharing of voter files across locality and state lines. Prosecution for people voting in more than one jusisdiction.
The range of allegations following the 2020 elections - illegal extension of the allowable voting period; defective voting machines; inner city machine control of polling stations; duplicate votes - have some validity, and should be pursued, but the election post mortems should focus on the big risk factor which can and must be fixed.
Let's get this right before the movement for internet voting emerges from the shadows.
bill bowen - 12/23/20